Cruise Register

The best Carnival ships for upkeep (condition)

Carnival Jubilee ranks first for upkeep (condition) at 4.4 out of 5 from 279 reviews, ahead of Carnival Panorama (4.3). Ranked from 6,341 passenger reviews of the ships ranked here.

Ranked by passenger reviewssailings Nov 2023–Nov 2026

How we score

Our own 1-5 scores per topic from passenger reviews of sailings since Nov 2023. The scores come from public passenger reviews of sailings in the last three years. The same review posted on more than one site counts once, and a language model scores every review on each topic against one fixed rubric, written before any scoring began. A ship is scored from 50 reviews and ranked from 100; topic scores from 50. After a major refit, the overall, cabins, upkeep and entertainment count only sailings since; crew, food and crowding keep three years. Until a refitted ship has 50 reviews since, it is ranked on its score from before the refit, labelled as such. Ship size by guests at double occupancy; where a line publishes only maximum capacity, it is divided by 1.2; with neither, by gross tonnage.

  1. Rank 1: Carnival Jubilee

    Mega · 5,362 guests

    Overall 3.9 · 389 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.4

    Above average

    279 reviews

    • Included food3.7
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins3.9
    • Shows4.1
    • Upkeep4.4
  2. Carnival Panorama

    Rank 2: Carnival Panorama

    Large · 3,340 guests

    Overall 3.8 · 322 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.3

    Above average

    221 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.3
    • Cabins4.3
    • Shows3.8
    • Upkeep4.3
  3. Carnival Spirit

    Rank 3: Carnival Spirit

    Midsize · 2,124 guests

    Overall 4.1 · 144 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.3

    Above average

    110 reviews

    • Included food3.8
    • Crew4.5
    • Cabins4.1
    • Shows4.1
    • Upkeep4.3
  4. Mardi Gras

    Rank 4: Mardi Gras

    Mega · 5,270 guests

    Overall 3.8 · 590 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.2

    Above average

    433 reviews

    • Included food3.6
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows4.1
    • Upkeep4.2
  5. Carnival Firenze

    Rank 6: Carnival Firenze

    Mega · 4,130 guests

    Overall 3.6 · 421 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.2

    Above average

    310 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.0
    • Cabins4.1
    • Shows3.8
    • Upkeep4.2

    Refitted Apr 2024: overall, cabins, upkeep and entertainment from 421 reviews since

  6. Carnival Venezia

    Rank 7: Carnival Venezia

    Large · 3,527 guests

    Overall 3.5 · 516 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.1

    Average

    396 reviews

    • Included food3.4
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows3.6
    • Upkeep4.1
  7. Carnival Miracle

    Rank 8: Carnival Miracle

    Midsize · 1,770 guests

    Overall 3.9 · 187 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.1

    Average

    140 reviews

    • Included food3.6
    • Crew4.4
    • Cabins4.2
    • Shows4.0
    • Upkeep4.1
  8. Carnival Pride

    Rank 9: Carnival Pride

    Midsize · 1,770 guests

    Overall 3.8 · 265 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.0

    Average

    211 reviews

    • Included food3.7
    • Crew4.5
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows3.9
    • Upkeep4.0
  9. Carnival Horizon

    Rank 10: Carnival Horizon

    Large · 3,300 guests

    Overall 3.7 · 444 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.9

    Average

    324 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins4.1
    • Shows3.9
    • Upkeep3.9
  10. Carnival Vista

    Rank 11: Carnival Vista

    Large · 3,278 guests

    Overall 3.5 · 525 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.8

    Average

    366 reviews

    • Included food3.4
    • Crew4.3
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows3.7
    • Upkeep3.8
  11. Carnival Elation

    Rank 12: Carnival Elation

    Midsize · 1,775 guests

    Overall 3.5 · 253 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.8

    Average

    183 reviews

    • Included food3.2
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins3.8
    • Shows3.7
    • Upkeep3.8
  12. Carnival Legend

    Rank 13: Carnival Legend

    Midsize · 2,233 guests

    Overall 3.7 · 174 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.8

    Average

    119 reviews

    • Included food3.4
    • Crew4.0
    • Cabins3.8
    • Shows3.8
    • Upkeep3.8
  13. Carnival Radiance

    Rank 14: Carnival Radiance

    Midsize · 2,303 guests

    Overall 3.5 · 327 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.7

    Average

    237 reviews

    • Included food3.4
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins3.9
    • Shows3.5
    • Upkeep3.7
  14. Carnival Freedom

    Rank 15: Carnival Freedom

    Midsize · 2,483 guests

    Overall 3.7 · 353 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.6

    Below average

    258 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.4
    • Cabins3.8
    • Shows3.9
    • Upkeep3.6
  15. Carnival Breeze

    Rank 16: Carnival Breeze

    Large · 3,075 guests

    Overall 3.6 · 337 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.5

    Below average

    237 reviews

    • Included food3.4
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins3.9
    • Shows3.8
    • Upkeep3.5
  16. Carnival Liberty

    Rank 17: Carnival Liberty

    Midsize · 2,478 guests

    Overall 3.6 · 287 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.5

    Below average

    220 reviews

    • Included food3.6
    • Crew4.3
    • Cabins3.7
    • Shows4.1
    • Upkeep3.5
  17. Carnival Paradise

    Rank 18: Carnival Paradise

    Midsize · 1,770 guests

    Overall 3.3 · 278 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.5

    Below average

    200 reviews

    • Included food3.3
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins3.5
    • Shows3.6
    • Upkeep3.5
  18. Carnival Sunshine

    Rank 19: Carnival Sunshine

    Large · 2,502 guests

    Overall 3.5 · 345 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.4

    Below average

    272 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins3.8
    • Shows3.7
    • Upkeep3.4
  19. Carnival Dream

    Rank 20: Carnival Dream

    Large · 3,038 guests

    Overall 3.5 · 295 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.4

    Below average

    230 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins3.7
    • Shows3.8
    • Upkeep3.4
  20. Carnival Glory

    Rank 21: Carnival Glory

    Midsize · 2,483 guests

    Overall 3.4 · 344 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.3

    Below average

    265 reviews

    • Included food3.3
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins3.6
    • Shows3.7
    • Upkeep3.3
  21. Carnival Conquest

    Rank 22: Carnival Conquest

    Midsize · 2,483 guests

    Overall 3.4 · 355 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.2

    Among the worst

    261 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins3.5
    • Shows3.9
    • Upkeep3.2
  22. Carnival Sunrise

    Rank 23: Carnival Sunrise

    Midsize · 2,487 guests

    Overall 3.3 · 313 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.2

    Among the worst

    237 reviews

    • Included food3.4
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins3.5
    • Shows3.6
    • Upkeep3.2
  23. Carnival Magic

    Rank 24: Carnival Magic

    Large · 3,075 guests

    Overall 3.3 · 296 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.1

    Among the worst

    226 reviews

    • Included food3.4
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins3.4
    • Shows3.6
    • Upkeep3.1
  24. Carnival Valor

    Rank 25: Carnival Valor

    Midsize · 2,483 guests

    Overall 3.9 · 74 reviews

    Upkeep

    3.0

    Among the worst

    107 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.3
    • Cabins4.1
    • Shows3.7
    • Upkeep3.0

    Refitted Jun 2025: overall, cabins, upkeep and entertainment from 74 reviews since

  25. Carnival Luminosa

    Rank 26: Carnival Luminosa

    Midsize · 2,355 guests

    Overall 3.0 · 155 reviews

    Upkeep

    2.9

    Among the worst

    114 reviews

    • Included food3.0
    • Crew3.9
    • Cabins3.6
    • Shows3.2
    • Upkeep2.9
  26. Carnival Adventure

    Rank 27: Carnival Adventure

    Large · 2,640 guests

    Overall 2.6 · 78 reviews

    Upkeep

    2.6

    Among the worst

    57 reviews

    • Included food2.6
    • Crew3.5
    • Shows2.9
    • Upkeep2.6

    Refitted Mar 2025: overall, cabins, upkeep and entertainment from 78 reviews since

Scored from sister ships

  1. Carnival Festivale

    Mega · 5,360 guests

    Overall 3.8 · 1,474 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.3

    Above average

    1,040 reviews

    • Included food3.6
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows4.0
    • Upkeep4.3

    Scored from Excel class · 1,474 reviews

  2. Carnival Tropicale

    Mega · 5,360 guests

    Overall 3.8 · 1,474 reviews

    Upkeep

    4.3

    Above average

    1,040 reviews

    • Included food3.6
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows4.0
    • Upkeep4.3

    Scored from Excel class · 1,474 reviews

  3. Carnival Encounter

    Large · 2,600 guests

    Overall 2.5 · 120 reviews

    Upkeep

    2.5

    Among the worst

    92 reviews

    • Included food2.5
    • Crew3.4
    • Cabins3.1
    • Shows3.0
    • Upkeep2.5

    Scored from Grand class (ex-P&O Australia) · 120 reviews

Best ships by line

Rankings

By traveller

By topic

Source: Cruise Register, Best Carnival Ships for Upkeep (Condition), https://www.cruiseregister.com/rankings/best-carnival-ships-for-upkeep/, prices checked .