Cruise Register

The best Carnival ships

Carnival Spirit ranks first at 4.1 out of 5 from 144 reviews, ahead of Carnival Jubilee (3.9). Ranked from 8,410 passenger reviews of the ships ranked here.

Ranked by passenger reviewssailings Nov 2023–Nov 2026

How we score

Our own 1-5 scores per topic from passenger reviews of sailings since Nov 2023. The scores come from public passenger reviews of sailings in the last three years. The same review posted on more than one site counts once, and a language model scores every review on each topic against one fixed rubric, written before any scoring began. A ship is scored from 50 reviews and ranked from 100. After a major refit, the overall, cabins, upkeep and entertainment count only sailings since; crew, food and crowding keep three years. Until a refitted ship has 50 reviews since, it is ranked on its score from before the refit, labelled as such. Ship size by guests at double occupancy; where a line publishes only maximum capacity, it is divided by 1.2; with neither, by gross tonnage. Ships sailing in the next 12 months without a rank are listed after the ranking as "not enough reviews yet": under 50 reviews, or 100 to be ranked.

  1. Mardi Gras

    Rank 4: Mardi Gras

    Mega · 5,270 guests

    3.8

    Above average

    590 reviews

    • Included food3.6
    • Crew4.2
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows4.1
    • Upkeep4.2
  2. Carnival Firenze

    Rank 11: Carnival Firenze

    Mega · 4,130 guests

    3.6

    Average

    421 reviews

    • Included food3.5
    • Crew4.0
    • Cabins4.1
    • Shows3.8
    • Upkeep4.2

    Refitted Apr 2024: overall, cabins, upkeep and entertainment from 421 reviews since

  3. Carnival Magic

    Rank 23: Carnival Magic

    Large · 3,075 guests

    3.3

    Below average

    296 reviews

    • Included food3.4
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins3.4
    • Shows3.6
    • Upkeep3.1

    Scored from reviews before its May 2026 refit

Scored from sister ships

  1. Carnival Festivale

    Mega · 5,360 guests

    3.8

    Above average

    1,474 reviews

    • Included food3.6
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows4.0
    • Upkeep4.3

    Scored from Excel class · 1,474 reviews

  2. Carnival Tropicale

    Mega · 5,360 guests

    3.8

    Above average

    1,474 reviews

    • Included food3.6
    • Crew4.1
    • Cabins4.0
    • Shows4.0
    • Upkeep4.3

    Scored from Excel class · 1,474 reviews

  3. Carnival Encounter

    Large · 2,600 guests

    2.5

    Among the worst

    120 reviews

    • Included food2.5
    • Crew3.4
    • Cabins3.1
    • Shows3.0
    • Upkeep2.5

    Scored from Grand class (ex-P&O Australia) · 120 reviews

Sailing, not ranked yet

Best ships by line

Rankings

By traveller

By topic

Source: Cruise Register, Best Carnival Ships, Ranked by Passenger Reviews, https://www.cruiseregister.com/rankings/best-carnival-ships/, prices checked .