Cruise Register

Cruise line comparisons

28 head-to-heads between 8 cruise lines, each scored from passenger reviews: overall, each topic and each type of traveller. A line is called higher at 0.2 apart on a 1-5 score with 100+ reviews on each side; closer is about the same.

Carnival

AgainstCarnivalOther lineOverall
vs Royal Caribbean3.64.0Royal Caribbean higher
vs Norwegian3.63.2Carnival higher
vs MSC3.63.4Carnival higher
vs Disney3.63.8Disney higher
vs Princess3.63.6About the same
vs Celebrity3.64.0Celebrity higher
vs Holland America3.63.8Holland America higher

Celebrity

AgainstCelebrityOther lineOverall
vs Princess4.03.6Celebrity higher
vs Carnival4.03.6Celebrity higher
vs Royal Caribbean4.04.0About the same
vs Norwegian4.03.2Celebrity higher
vs MSC4.03.4Celebrity higher
vs Disney4.03.8Celebrity higher
vs Holland America4.03.8Celebrity higher

Disney

AgainstDisneyOther lineOverall
vs Carnival3.83.6Disney higher
vs Royal Caribbean3.84.0Royal Caribbean higher
vs Norwegian3.83.2Disney higher
vs MSC3.83.4Disney higher
vs Princess3.83.6Disney higher
vs Celebrity3.84.0Celebrity higher
vs Holland America3.83.8About the same

Holland America

AgainstHolland AmericaOther lineOverall
vs Princess3.83.6Holland America higher
vs Carnival3.83.6Holland America higher
vs Royal Caribbean3.84.0Royal Caribbean higher
vs Norwegian3.83.2Holland America higher
vs MSC3.83.4Holland America higher
vs Disney3.83.8About the same
vs Celebrity3.84.0Celebrity higher

MSC

AgainstMSCOther lineOverall
vs Royal Caribbean3.44.0Royal Caribbean higher
vs Carnival3.43.6Carnival higher
vs Norwegian3.43.2MSC higher
vs Disney3.43.8Disney higher
vs Princess3.43.6Princess higher
vs Celebrity3.44.0Celebrity higher
vs Holland America3.43.8Holland America higher

Norwegian

AgainstNorwegianOther lineOverall
vs Royal Caribbean3.24.0Royal Caribbean higher
vs Carnival3.23.6Carnival higher
vs MSC3.23.4MSC higher
vs Disney3.23.8Disney higher
vs Princess3.23.6Princess higher
vs Celebrity3.24.0Celebrity higher
vs Holland America3.23.8Holland America higher

Princess

AgainstPrincessOther lineOverall
vs Celebrity3.64.0Celebrity higher
vs Holland America3.63.8Holland America higher
vs Carnival3.63.6About the same
vs Royal Caribbean3.64.0Royal Caribbean higher
vs Norwegian3.63.2Princess higher
vs MSC3.63.4Princess higher
vs Disney3.63.8Disney higher

Royal Caribbean

AgainstRoyal CaribbeanOther lineOverall
vs Carnival4.03.6Royal Caribbean higher
vs Norwegian4.03.2Royal Caribbean higher
vs MSC4.03.4Royal Caribbean higher
vs Disney4.03.8Royal Caribbean higher
vs Princess4.03.6Royal Caribbean higher
vs Celebrity4.04.0About the same
vs Holland America4.03.8Royal Caribbean higher

Rankings