Carnival vs Holland America: what passengers say
Holland America scores higher overall: 3.8 vs 3.6 out of 5, and on 4 of 6 topics and traveller types (Carnival on 1); about the same on crew (4.2 vs 4.3).
Ranked by passenger reviewssailings Nov 2023–Nov 2026
How we score
Our own 1-5 scores per topic from passenger reviews; each line's score is the review-weighted mean of its ships with 50+ reviews. The scores come from public passenger reviews of sailings in the last three years. The same review posted on more than one site counts once, and a language model scores every review on each topic against one fixed rubric, written before any scoring began. A topic counts as a win at 0.2 apart, and as about the same when closer, both only with 100+ reviews on each side. Fleet: scheduled sailings in the next 12 months; typical ship size from guests at double occupancy.
In short
- Choose Carnival for entertainment: passengers rate it higher (entertainment 3.8 vs 3.6).
- Choose Holland America for food, upkeep and cabins: passengers rate it higher (food 3.9 vs 3.5, upkeep 4.1 vs 3.7, cabins 4.1 vs 3.9).
- They rate about the same (within 0.2) on crew.
- Carnival's ships are a median 21 years old and Holland America's 20 (30 ships and 11 ships sailing in the next 12 months).
- Carnival is cheaper in 12 of 12 like-for-like price comparisons (6–8 nights, inside: $232 a night for two, all-in, against $380 with Holland America).
Ships and sailings
Carnival
Holland America
Questions
Is Carnival better than Holland America?
Holland America: passengers rate it 3.8 out of 5 against 3.6.
Which has better food, Carnival or Holland America?
Holland America: passengers rate it 3.9 out of 5 against 3.5.
Which has better entertainment, Carnival or Holland America?
Carnival: passengers rate it 3.8 out of 5 against 3.6.
Is Carnival or Holland America better for couples?
Holland America: passengers rate it 4.2 out of 5 against 3.9.
Is Carnival or Holland America cheaper?
Carnival is cheaper for a typical 6–8-night cruise in an inside cabin: $232 a night for two with Carnival against $380 with Holland America, all-in (median of 1,625 and 433 sailings). Across 12 trip lengths and cabins, Carnival is cheaper in 12 and Holland America in none.
More comparisons
Source: Cruise Register, Carnival vs Holland America: Passenger Reviews Compared, https://www.cruiseregister.com/compare/carnival-vs-holland-america/, scores updated .