Cruise Register

Carnival vs Holland America: what passengers say

Holland America scores higher overall: 3.8 vs 3.6 out of 5, and on 4 of 6 topics and traveller types (Carnival on 1); about the same on crew (4.2 vs 4.3).

Ranked by passenger reviewssailings Nov 2023–Nov 2026

How we score

Our own 1-5 scores per topic from passenger reviews; each line's score is the review-weighted mean of its ships with 50+ reviews. The scores come from public passenger reviews of sailings in the last three years. The same review posted on more than one site counts once, and a language model scores every review on each topic against one fixed rubric, written before any scoring began. A topic counts as a win at 0.2 apart, and as about the same when closer, both only with 100+ reviews on each side. Fleet: scheduled sailings in the next 12 months; typical ship size from guests at double occupancy.

Carnival

28 ships scored

3.6

Average

8,615 reviews

Holland America

10 ships scored

3.8

Average

1,793 reviews

In short

  • Choose Carnival for entertainment: passengers rate it higher (entertainment 3.8 vs 3.6).
  • Choose Holland America for food, upkeep and cabins: passengers rate it higher (food 3.9 vs 3.5, upkeep 4.1 vs 3.7, cabins 4.1 vs 3.9).
  • They rate about the same (within 0.2) on crew.
  • Carnival's ships are a median 21 years old and Holland America's 20 (30 ships and 11 ships sailing in the next 12 months).
  • Carnival is cheaper in 12 of 12 like-for-like price comparisons (6–8 nights, inside: $232 a night for two, all-in, against $380 with Holland America).
Scores out of 5
Overall
3.68,615 reviews
3.8 (higher)1,793 reviews
Included food
3.57,252 reviews
3.9 (higher)1,759 reviews
Crew
4.27,518 reviews
4.31,814 reviews
Cabins
3.96,557 reviews
4.1 (higher)1,442 reviews
Shows
3.8 (higher)6,333 reviews
3.61,395 reviews
Upkeep
3.76,341 reviews
4.1 (higher)1,335 reviews
Couples
3.92,786 reviews
4.2 (higher)284 reviews
Fleets, next 12 months
Ships
30 sailing
11 sailing
Sailings
1,706
578
Median ship age
21 years
20 years
Ship sizes
Mega 5 · Large 11 · Midsize 14
Midsize 11
Refitted since 2023
23
8

Ships and sailings

Questions

Is Carnival better than Holland America?

Holland America: passengers rate it 3.8 out of 5 against 3.6.

Which has better food, Carnival or Holland America?

Holland America: passengers rate it 3.9 out of 5 against 3.5.

Which has better entertainment, Carnival or Holland America?

Carnival: passengers rate it 3.8 out of 5 against 3.6.

Is Carnival or Holland America better for couples?

Holland America: passengers rate it 4.2 out of 5 against 3.9.

Is Carnival or Holland America cheaper?

Carnival is cheaper for a typical 6–8-night cruise in an inside cabin: $232 a night for two with Carnival against $380 with Holland America, all-in (median of 1,625 and 433 sailings). Across 12 trip lengths and cabins, Carnival is cheaper in 12 and Holland America in none.

More comparisons

Source: Cruise Register, Carnival vs Holland America: Passenger Reviews Compared, https://www.cruiseregister.com/compare/carnival-vs-holland-america/, scores updated .